Hokanson v. Zeigler

Under an installment sales contract for patent from the State Board of University and School Lands, the State retains the legal title to the property and holds it in trust for the purchaser and as security for the purchaser's compliance with the contract. The purchaser of such land holds equitable title until the terms of the installment sales contract have been completed and a patent has been issued, at which time the legal title merges with the equitable title. Completion of the terms of the installment sales contract for patent perfects title relating back to the date of the contract. In 2014, Curtis and Joan Hokanson ("Hokansons") initiated a quiet title action naming Corrine Zeigler, Charles Zeigler, Bonnie Scharback, Terry Scharback, Bruce Bibler, Beverly Bibler, Delton R. Bibler, Lee Bibler, Curtis D. Bibler, Carol M. Bibler, Gerald Bibler, Alice Bibler, Trudy Mathae, Bruce Mathae, Howard L. Bibler, Continental Resources, Inc., and all other persons unknown ("Biblers") claiming any estate or interest in, or lien or encumbrance upon, the property described in the complaint as defendants. In 1957, the Board of University and School Lands of the State of North Dakota and Edson and June Bibler entered into an installment sale contract for the purchase of the land at issue here. Prior to the initiation of the quiet title action by the Hokansons, the Biblers entered into oil and gas leases in 2013. The Biblers were named as the lessors, and the lessee in all the leases was Continental Resources. All leases were dated July 9, 2013. The Hokansons claimed they had title to an undivided 50% mineral interest under the property. The Hokansons argued they received this interest because the subject property was conveyed to them from Hans Hanson (the Hokansons' predecessor-in-interest) with no reservations of mineral interest appearing in a 1971 Warranty Deed. The Hokansons argued the predecessor in interest to Hans Hanson was the State of North Dakota who conveyed to Hans Hanson the surface and 50% of the mineral interest by a 1971 Patent. The district court entered an order granting the Biblers' motion for summary judgment. After review, and finding no reversible error in that judgment, the North Dakota Supreme Court affirmed. View "Hokanson v. Zeigler" on Justia Law